Marco Polo (Season One)

I’ve just finished season one of Marco Polo on Netflix and I have to admit to quite enjoying it. That “I have to admit” is mostly for myself, as I watched the first two episodes about a year ago when it originally came out and walked away. I had to get myself into the Braveheart meets Gladiator zone of “historical” entertainment and then it worked. It’s enjoyable with some fun characters, smarmy intrigue, good martial arts and absolutely horrible battlefield scenes.

So this isn’t about Marco Polo. Well, it is, but it is in the same way that Forrest Gump is about late 20th century history. Polo gets shoe-horned into a bunch of important points in the period, even when he should not be there. The series understands that we basically know that Marco Polo went to China and that’s about it. We know the Mongols were tough as nails and were barbarians. That’s the level of knowledge this series assumes you have and if you have more than that, you might not have a good time. That is, until you get into that headspace that allows for the return to the Roman Republic after Commodus’ assassination and Franco-Scot noble William Wallace dressing like a 17th century Highlander while usurping Robert the Bruce’s pivotal role in assuring Scots’ independence in the 14th century.

The writing is fine but it’s not original. There’s a lot of stock characters, stock dialogue, and stock political tension and intrigue. Marco Polo gets to be involved in the aspects of Kublai Khan’s reign and conflict with Song Dynasty China that he almost certainly was not. He also gets to learn martial arts from a blind monk, and that’s really what I came back for. That was so much like Nefertiti Overdrive – throw in some martial arts, it’ll make it better! – that I had to come back. And I am glad I did.

Marco Polo is absolutely not great, but darn is it entertaining. It’s also nice the number of roles it provides for non-White actors. Heck, even the main Caucasian isn’t North American. He certainly did better with martial arts than Iron Fist did in Iron Fist. In fact, I would have been happier to have Claudia Kim (Khutulun), Tom Wu (Hundred Eyes) or Chin Han (Jia Sidao) play Danny Rand in Iron Fist given how well they pull off their fight scenes.

But this is bad history. The broad strokes are fine, but the details are almost all wrong. And the battle scenes do not please me. There are some great fight scenes – when it’s character fighting character – but when the Mongol host faces the Chinese army it really fails. I mean, it’s not alone in this – I’m looking at you, the Two Towers, with your cavalry charge downhill on loose shale, and you, the Return of the King, with another cavalry charge against a wall . . . a wall! Still, those scenes were merciful few and relatively short, whereas the rest of the series is pretty fun.

I give Marco Polo season one four hastily erected for false tension trebuchets out of five. That’s for entertainment value rather than quality. It’s a great costumer with action and drama, and a lot of fun characters and situations that draws one along with its story even when one is shaking one’s head.

Posted in Review | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Marco Polo (Season One)

New Daughters, New Glory

I’ve written before about the novel I was working on called Daughter of Glory. About a year ago, I was looking at updating it and considering how I might best present it. Just recently I was plotting out a story of two young sisters who are caught up in political and religious turmoil that separates them from their parents. I recognize the similarity of the two stories and was thinking I could merge them, bolt the story of the two sisters onto Daughter of Glory.

But that’s a bad idea for two reasons: 1) it will never fit perfectly and 2) even trying to do so is lazy.

“Sorceress” by nanami-yuki

Daughter of Glory was high fantasy with elves and dwarves and archmages throwing lightning around. I envisioned the two sisters’ story (let’s just call it Two Sisters) as low fantasy, with some magic but no other races. Cultures, oh my yes, but not elves, dwarves, fairies or orcs. The amount of re-working that would need to happen would be immense and would likely show.

And, really, why would I even want to? Yes, I had a huge amount already finished on Daughter of Glory, and that might give me a leg up (not necessarily would, but might), but that’s its own kind of trap. Have I not learned anything since I originally wrote those words? Am I not a different writer now than then? I believe the answer to both is yes. Using the words written by that other writer, that me from many years ago, is a cheat that could lead to a worse product. It might be easier, but easier is not better.

So in the end, I think I need to pursue Two Sisters and abandon Daughter of Glory. If I do want to return to Daughter of Glory, I need to use that which is written as a guideline, rather than a shortcut. Those words were written, and they served their purpose – practice. The development of that idea helped me to improve my writing. Its work is done.

But my work goes on.

You can read more about Daughter of Glory here.

Art for this article from nanami-yuki at deviantART.

Posted in Fiction, Writing | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on New Daughters, New Glory

Wonder Woman, A Review

On Father’s Day I had the rare opportunity to view a movie in its native environment – the theatre. The whole family went to check out Wonder Woman, and I am so glad that we did – certainly for my wife and daughters but also absolutely for me.

There are certainly problems with this movie, and if an “Everything Wrong With . . .” video happens, it’ll probably reach into 20 minute+ territory, but y’know what? I couldn’t care less. We could do the same with Superman or Raiders of the Lost Ark. Don’t care. Love those movies, and I love this one.

Do I need to explain the plot? It’s World War I and an errant American spy working for British intelligence breaches the isolation of Themyscira where we have watched a young girl grow into a consummate warrior. Her sense of honour forces her to leave her home because she believes she can help stop the war and save innocent lives.

To say this is a bright film misses the fact that it focuses on the tragedy of war, both for those involved in the fighting and for those caught in the middle. But it is a bright film – bright like Superman, and a recent Directors’ Guild of America interview with director Patty Jenkins reveals the truth of this. Superman was an inspiration to her, and in the interview she explains to its director – Richard Donner – just how much he influenced and inspired her.

This movie honestly has everything I love: great action, solid characters, heroics, nobility, and a light touch. The actors inhabit the roles and even the supporting cast are given enough personality to make me care about them, and each had a few moments to shine. None of this matters if the main actor isn’t believable and charismatic. Gal Gadot is both. She really embodies Wonder Woman in the way that Christopher Reeve embodied Superman and the way I think Chris Evans embodies Captain America. These characters are all noble warriors who fight not because of a love of war but to protect those who cannot fight for themselves. They are selfless and truly heroic. The movie delivers on this.

My daughters loved the movie. I can’t say it was a revelatory to them as many situations related elsewhere, but they were very pleased to see a woman be the hero and the leader. My wife may have loved it more than my daughters, saying it was great to see a woman who was so physically dominant, so capable, and unyielding in her beliefs and righteousness.

I got to say, I feel the same.

I give Wonder Woman 4.5 invisible invisible planes out of 5. This is a fantastically enjoyable movie that has some plot holes and other problems, but I could not care less about it. This is an amazing movie and the easily rivals Nolan’s first two Batman movies and Donner’s Superman as the best DC superhero movie.

You can find out more about Wonder Woman at Wikipedia and IMDB.

You can hear the Patty Jenkins interview here.

You don’t know about the “Everything Wrong With . . .” videos on Youtube?

Posted in Review | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Wonder Woman, A Review

I’m An Imposter

In honour of the Imposters funding (Todd Crapper and Josh T. Jordan on the same project? The collected awesome of that project will undoubtedly create a singularity of awesome, but instead of nothing escaping the event horizon, it will constantly release awesome into the universe), let me put on my imposter hair-shirt for just a moment.

Recently, people gave me a bunch of money to update Sword’s Edge. They continue to drop money they have earned with their hard work to get me to ship physical products to them. Somewhere else on the internet today, somebody bought a bunch of adventures I wrote between 2004 and 2005 (with a slight detour into 2008). Every time I look at the amount of money somebody spends on my stuff I get the feeling that they are going to be the one to realize I am a fraud. That they are going to turn around and say: “Why am I paying you for this shit? You suck at this.”

I was the spotlight author in issue 79 of the Canadian speculative fiction magazine On Spec and I described myself as a hack. That’s kind of how I have always envisioned myself. I am a worker, not an artist. If I get paid for stuff, it’s because it’s good enough, not because it is good.

I read games that other designers create and I read fiction that other authors write and I am often inspired to attack my own work with more gusto, but then I look at my stuff and I compare it to their stuff and I often think that the world would be better off if I just stopped.

The weird thing is that while people paying money can trigger this, the fact that people will pay me money is one of the signals that I use to continue to work. There are people who have bought all my games, and that boggles my mind. There are people in this world that actually see my name attached to something and decide to buy it. It is really weird to both be terrified and energized by the fact that people pay money for my stuff, but there it is.

I’m an imposter. Please feel free to be that person who calls me on my BS.

You can find out more about the Imposters here.

The amazing Josh T Jordan runs Ginger Goat.

The awesome Todd Crapper runs Broken Ruler Games.

You can read some reviews of On Spec issue 79 and my place in it, both complimentary and not so much.

Posted in Personal | Tagged , , , | 4 Comments

Through the Gate in the Sea: A Review

I was quite thrilled when I heard that Through the Gate in the Sea was available. I’m a fan of Howard Andrew Jones’ work, and while I consider his non-tie-in fiction to be his strongest, I will always buy a book with his name on it. As such, I have all four of his Pathfinder novels. As you might imagine, I’m positively inclined toward his fiction, so that’s the bias I bring to this review.

I have a hard time deciding if I like this or its predecessor, Beyond the Pool of Stars, better. Like Beyond the Pool of Stars, Through the Gate in the Sea reads much more like heroic fantasy with touches of epic fantasy rather than gaming fiction. There are hints throughout that yes, this is rooted in the rules and expectations of a role-playing game, but this does not dominate the flavour of the book. If you cringe at tie-in fiction – which I honestly generally do with a couple of exceptions – you needn’t fear this novel. It is not as strong as the Desert of Souls or the Bones of the Old Ones – Howard Andrew Jones’ two novels with Dabir and Asim, his best works for certain – but it is riveting.

Basically, Through the Gate in the Sea takes off soon after Beyond the Pool of Stars ends, with main character Mirian Raas, a marine salvager, trying to help the lizardfolk with whom she has forged a familial bond, find more of their lost people. This allows for one of the best POV characters in the novel: Jekka, a lizardfolk warrior. Jekka is Mirian’s blood brother, and while he is a cool customer, the chance to find more of his people after losing all of his clan save his cousin, fires him up.

There’s a great villain, a fantastic anti-hero with whom I can definitely sympathize, the playwright-hero Ivrian, and much more. The characters are all excellent and believable, but this – along with brisk, exciting pacing and swashbuckling action – is one of Howard Andrew Jones’ strengths.

The only quibble I have with the novel is that there is a group of adversaries that seem unnecessary. They have a function in the story, but then kind of drift off and don’t have a really impactful exit. I was expecting more given how well Howard Andrew Jones sculpted the main character of this group, and I don’t really want to say more so as not to spoil anyone’s suspense. It’s funny, because I can easily imagine in real-life this exact situation – oh jeez, those guys are pretty tough, this could be a problem . . . wait, what happened to them? In fiction, though, one carries expectations. So maybe I’m talking myself out of the quibble in that it’s actually believable in the way that reality is crazier than any fiction, but for the story I would say I didn’t find it satisfying.

That one quibble apart, Howard Andrew Jones delivered exactly what his name on a cover promises – strong plot, exciting action, and great characters. That’s what I love.

I give Through the Gate in the Sea 4.75 non-submersible, highly mobile, undersea transports out of 5. If you dig fantasy – and especially if you dig heroic fantasy with a hint of high magic and epic threats – you’ll dig this. As with all of his books, I highly recommend this Howard Andrew Jones novel.

You can find Through the Gate in the Sea at Paizo here and Amazon here.

You can learn more about Howard Andrew Jones here.

I reviewed Beyond the Pool of Stars here.

Posted in Review | Tagged , , , , | Comments Off on Through the Gate in the Sea: A Review

Logan: A Review

Thanks to the wonders of repertory cinemas, I had a chance to see Logan last week. It seems this was good karma for helping a friend in need, and it was more than an adequate reward.

I’ve been a Wolverine fan for quite some time. It’s likely because he was the first mainstream Canadian superhero teenage me found, but there were also some very significant Wolverine stories back in the day, and the Wolverine mini-series written by Chris Claremont and illustrated by Frank Miller cemented Logan as my favourite super. When James Mangold seemed to be bringing aspects of that mini-series to the screen in The Wolverine, I was cautiously excited – cautious because of X3 and X-Men Origins: Wolverine.

The Wolverine was certainly better than XMOW, but it didn’t do the mini-series justice. Still, it seemed like it would be the best we would get. Then along comes Logan and its obvious borrowings from Old Man Logan.

Let’s be clear: Old Man Logan worked very well as a deconstruction of many comic characters and tropes, but much of what the work referenced would be lost on movie audiences. Many of the story points would be likewise pretty extreme (like the Hulk clan’s origins). However, I thought an older, bitter Logan would be a great character and with the rumours that this would be Hugh Jackman’s last hurrah as Wolverine, a story taking aspects from Old Man Logan sounded perfect.

Logan is not perfect, but I think it’s as close to that as we can expect. There were parts of the film that dragged for me, but I recognize their purpose. Jackman and Patrick Stewart deliver, and Dafne Keen as X-23 was also quite good. Sometimes Boyd Holbrook as Donald Pierce or Richard E. Grant as Zander Rice chew some scenery, but it is relatively restrained for what it is and likely an attempt to make the villains more entertaining, given that they are evil guys doing evil things with flimsy justifications – they are 2D villains pretty much.

The weakness of the villains, though, didn’t detract from my enjoyment of the movie, and enjoy it I did. While there were few surprises – as much as I hoped there’d be a curveball somewhere along the way – it was a fantastic ride. This is the Wolverine movie all others should aspire to be. And I believe there should be other Wolverine movies with a new Logan now that Hugh Jackman has departed. Like Sean Connery’s Bond, whomever follows Jackman is going to have a hard time of it, but I wish them well.

Along with the pathos, there is lots of action, and it is good without being great. There were no action scenes that left me stunned, nothing here that I had not seen before elsewhere, but that’s okay. Again, given this intellectual property’s track record, good translates to great when you are in the theatre watching the movie.

So I’m going to give Logan 4.5 unmentioned spoiler special villains out of 5. Although there were no surprises, the action was good and the acting from the leads was great. The movie could have been improved by taking some chances with the plot or making the villains more believable, but this was a

Posted in Review | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Logan: A Review

Hard West

Since I have put my master’s program on pause, I’ve had some time to play some computer games, and an interesting one that I’ve just started is Hard West.

Now, being a PC player, I don’t have access to Red Dead Redemption. I really liked Call of Juarez: Bound in Blood and Gunslinger, but the only other Western-themed computer game I’ve been recommended is Gun, which I started but which never really held my interest. Hard West is something different – a turn-based tactical shooter. That’s cool, because gunfighting is what I was looking for, but the story elements are a bit lacking. Not that there’s not a story, there are multiple stories, but the player’s input into the stories is minimal. This is the same as the Call of Juarez games, which are Western shooters on rails.

Right now, I’m finding the game fun and the mechanics of the fights – with the importance of cover in reducing damage, and the importance of luck in avoiding getting shot – but it’d be nice if there was more customization of the characters and less of a railroaded story. The graphics are quite good, but it takes a while to figure out how to do anything on the map, and I started my second playthrough after a couple of scenarios as I began to realize just what I could do.

I may need to get back to Gun and see if maybe my initial impression was perhaps too quickly formed.

I would give Hard West three and three-quarters rounds from a Volcano pistol out of five (And, yes, Hard West does have a version of hard-hitting hand cannon from Volcanic Repeating Arms). It has a great combat system and graphics, but it is lacking in character customization and player input into the story.

You can find out more about Hard West here.

It is available on Steam here.

Posted in Review | Tagged , , | Comments Off on Hard West

Artist as Protagonist

A recent episode of In Our Time focused on the Japanese artist Hokusai, and the discussion turned to Japan at the time and Hokusai’s place in both the artistic community and the politics of the time – he apparently had a good relationship with the Shogun. It made me think of the artist as a protagonist outside the changes to a nation or culture but who can be a lens to view that.

I’ve had a few false starts with these kinds of stories, originally inspired by the movie Painted Fire (Chi Hwa Sun – not See Uhn as the announcer in the trailer pronounces it). This was a movie by Im Kwon-Taek, who is the finest Korean director bar none in my opinion, and starring one of Korea’s greatest living actors, Choi Min-Sik. The difference was that while the character of Jang Seung-Up was also an entré character for the politics of that period, he did not have the self-awareness or the savvy of Hokusai – at least as the one is portrayed in the movie and the other in the podcast. I think both would be interesting, with Hokusai much more of an insider and Jang much more of a rebel.

Guy Gavriel Kay used this device in his Sarantine Mosaic duology – Sailing to Sarantium and Lord of Emperors – in which a mosaic artist is plucked out of the settings version of Italy following the fall of its Roman Empire and whisked away to Sarantium – the stand-in for Constantinople. Crispin, the artist-protagonist in this story, is a mixture of the two. He’s not as worldly as Hokusai and not as wild as Jang Seung-Up.

All that to say I think the device would be a lot of fun to play with, but I would need a story in which it could work. Further, I think the character could work really well in a story-centric RPG in which the artistic ability might be useful in some abstract way. Were I to play one, it would definitely be much more Jang Seung-Up, with a large helping of uncertainty and confusion that people actually care about what he’s producing.

By the way, on the day this is published (11 Apr 2017) there are still a few more days on the Sword’s Edge Kickstarter. Head on over an back it if you haven’t already. Thanks!

You can find the “Hokusai” episode of In Our Time here.

You can find information on Painted Fire here and the trailer here.

You can read about the Sarantine Mosaic here.

Posted in Fiction, Writing | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments Off on Artist as Protagonist

Sword’s Edge on Kickstarter

In case you didn’t know, I’ve got a Kickstarter going for a new edition of Sword’s Edge. I think it’s awesome, but then again, I’m biased. Still, you should check it out.

Posted in News, Role-Playing Games | Tagged , , , | Comments Off on Sword’s Edge on Kickstarter

Marvel’s Iron Fist – the First Seven Episodes

I’m up to episode 7 in the Netflix series Marvel’s Iron Fist and while it’s fine, I find it the weakest of the Marvel series. Without getting into spoilers, the main character is pretty wooden and this is not offset by his martial abilities. Choices made in changing the character and mythos seem poorly considered to me, or at best simply cliched. The dialogue is unimpressive and the plot seems padded.

In the end, for a series about a living weapon, the action is good but not impressive and the story seems afraid to embrace the idea of warrior-monk.

I’m disappointed in the series but will watch it to its end. It reminds me of living in the pre-Marvel Studios age where comic fans thirsted for any appearance of their favourite characters in any incarnation, and we had to put up with poor interpretations of characters to see them in live action at all. I remember being thrilled with Daredevil and Thor appearing in the Incredible Hulk TV movies in the late 1980s. Those were pretty bad renditions of the characters, but it’s all we had. Iron Fist is of better quality than those, but it’s that same disappointment tinged with appreciation that there is something.

I would give the first seven episodes of Marvel’s Iron Fist 3.5 chi-focused living weapon strikes out of 5. The story was plodding, the action mediocre, and the dialogue weak. It was fine but unimpressive and the changes to Iron Fist didn’t improve the character at all.

Okay, so to delve into that, I need to touch on some aspects of the story. I’m going to try to avoid real spoilers, but the further in I get, the more I’m going to need to refer to events in the series, so you have been warned.

Turn back now if you would like to avoid spoilers.

Last chance, spoilers ahead.


Okay, so right off the bat, we have very few fights for a series about a living weapon who became the Iron First by besting all other warrior-monks in a series of challenges. Until episode 6 (directed by RZA, the man behind the fun but weak Man With the Iron FIsts . . . coincidence?) we get Danny Rand/Iron Fist getting into minor dust-ups, and he is unimpressive in all of them. The fights might be considered good for network TV, but Netflix and Marvel can do better. They should do better. As poor as Sword of Destiny, the Netflix sequel to Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon was, at least the fights were pretty good. Heck, I was more impressed with the fight scenes in Daredevil than with this, and while Daredevil is also supposed to be a highly capable martial artist, this is Iron Fist. Martial arts is his one and only thing. Daredevil has enhanced senses and his radar as part of his schtick. Iron Fist only has martial arts.

Now, if the actor who played Iron Fist delivered an amazing performance, I might be willing to accept the mediocre martial arts, but Finn Jones is fine but not great – much like his martial arts performance. Either give us a stellar actor or an amazing martial artist. Listen, Keanu Reeves did great in the Matrix and Donnie Yen’s performance in Rogue One was actually quite good, so this is definitely possible. It just takes will and effort, and apparently Scott Buck, the show runner for Iron Fist, did not have these, or simply though it was “good enough.” It isn’t.

So much of the first half of this series is Iron Fist recovering his identify as Danny Rand and the machinations of the Meachum family to keep Danny from his place as head of Rand. The plotting of this wasn’t bad, but other than the situation of the father, the characters were all stereotypical. There’s not much fresh here and it really seemed like padding. What did this bring to the story of Iron Fist? With Daredevil, Matt Murdock working as a lawyer was integral to the story of Daredevil. It always has been. Danny Rand’s links to Rand were sometimes used in Iron Fist stories, but – especially in the recent incarnation written by Ed Brubaker and Matt Fraction – this was background never a focus. I know that Iron Fist’s relations with the Meachums were included in past stories, but that was “bussiness person as villain” comic book stuff, not this focus on boardrooms and lawyers. In the most recent (and I would argue best) incarnation of Iron Fist, Rand was sometimes used to initiate action, but it was never Iron Fist fighting for Rand, it was something happening at Rand that touched on Iron Fist’s story.

Again, if some of this stuff was actually fresh, if it explored something that helped illuminate the character, that would have been fine – though it should have taken a backseat to the story of the living weapon. This series is called Iron Fist, and the opening credits has a great digitally created show of fighting skills – if only the lead could perform as well – but for the first five episodes, it certainly seemed like the show should be called Rand as Iron Fist seemed a B- or C-plot.

And, come on, how could Iron Fist not understand that talking about K’un Lun being in a different dimension would cause problems He lived much of his life in the US and understood things like phones and cars, so how would he not realize talking about other dimensions would make people question the veracity of his story? It was lazy writing creating false obstacles in an effort to create tension that would not have occurred if the protagonist wasn’t an idiot. Yes, it was an idiot plot.

I have a sneaking suspicion that either there was only enough story for half a season and the show runner wanted to stretch it out or this was an attempt to “do something different.” Bringing a different lens to a story is not necessarily a problem, but it bugs me that Iron Fist was the only character they felt needed to have his story changed. The other three Netflix Marvel series hew pretty close to the story of those characters, with some additions and changes but very little fundamental to the character. Iron Fist is the first time that the character and his story has been fundamentally changed.

Iron Fist is not conflicted about his role as a living weapon. He might have issues with the leader of K’un Lun – Yu-Ti, the August Personage in Jade – but not with being the Iron Fist in general. This was the part that bothered me the most. Luke Cage as a reluctant hero makes sense, as does Jessica Jones, but Iron Fist is more like Daredevil – he chose this. This is what he wants. He revels in being a living weapon and he believes in the mission of the Iron Fist – to stand against the storm when no one else can. He is unabashedly heroic.

And it was really minor, but I hated the idea of him getting stronger by being hit. That worked for Rocky but it’s the antithesis of a good martial artist – and Iron Fist is supposed to be one of the best. It may have been planting the seeds for his escape from the psychiatric ward, but that whole storyline was – frankly – silly. If the idea was that we would question Danny’s story, that wasn’t laid out well, and if not, then what was the point? It was clumsy and it was cliched.

And on a final note, I was thrilled when Iron Fist referred to K’un Lun as one of the seven capital cities of heaven, which led me to hope we might see some of the other Immortal Weapons. When the challenge from the Hand came, I thought for a moment we were going to get the Bride of Nine Spiders, but then the writers created a stereotypical seductress. Don’t tell me they couldn’t find a competent and capable actor for the role, given that Colleen Wing is a much better martial artist on screen than Danny Rand. Nope, instead we had standard casting villains of taunting badguys and sexual femme fatales. Boring. Why not give us a warrior who understands that he or she is facing the Iron Fist and is excited about the prospect of really testing their skills. Give Iron Fist an opponent who is serious and respectful, not necessarily honourable, but something different.

So, yeah, I wasn’t happy with so much of the first five episodes, and was happier with the sixth, but underwhelmed by the action.

Posted in Review | Tagged , , , , , | Comments Off on Marvel’s Iron Fist – the First Seven Episodes